Publication
Title
Permanent neutrality or permanent insecurity? Obligation and self-interest in the defence of Belgian neutrality, 1830-1870
Author
Abstract
The permanent or compulsory nature of Belgian neutrality, from the country’s inception (1830–1839) to the Franco-Prussian war (1870) is has generally been left to political or diplomatic historians. The guarantors of Belgian independence had made their enduring support conditional on the respect of the obligations of neutrality. Legal historians should consider that political and diplomatic exchanges were steeped in international law-discourse. In early modern doctrine, a state’s decision to remain neutral during a conflict between third states could be reversed when necessary. The permanent nature of these restrictions meant the latter had become impossible. The Belgian government pleaded for a restrictive reading of limitations to its sovereignty. Rights and obligations were presented as mutually dependent. This played out favourably during the ‘War of the Triple Alliance’ (1864–1870), exports to Brazil could go on, even if its opponent, Paraguay suffered a blockade. Franco-British pressure forced the Belgian government to downplay its ambitions in 1854, during the Crimean War. Even if arms were supplied to all parties in the conflict. When guarantors were involved in a conflict, neutrality became a nearly prohibitive burden. British sympathy for the Belgian liberal constitutional system could not override basic geopolitical interests and French pressure.
Language
English
Source (book)
International law in the long nineteenth century (1776-1914): from the public law of Europe to global international law? / Van Hulle, Inge [edit.]; et al.
Source (series)
Legal history library ; 28
Publication
Leiden : Brill , 2019
ISBN
978-90-04-41208-8
DOI
10.1163/9789004412088_009
Volume/pages
p. 159-185
Note
Studies in the history of international law ; 11
Full text (Publisher's DOI)
UAntwerpen
Faculty/Department
Research group
Publication type
Subject
Law 
Affiliation
Publications with a UAntwerp address
External links
VABB-SHW
Record
Identifier
Creation 03.10.2019
Last edited 07.10.2022
To cite this reference