Publication
Title
Others on trial: the construction of cultural otherness in Belgian first instance criminal hearings
Author
Abstract
This paper presents an ethnographic account of how cultural otherness is discursively constructed in Belgian first instance criminal courtrooms, based on field observations and on the analysis of transcribed video-recordings. It contrasts unproblematic culturalizations of deviant conduct, in which mentioning the defendants cultural identity does not interfere with the smooth progression of discourse, with cases in which the foregrounding of their identity as a minority-member results in the silencing of the defendants. The identity of the participant initiating culturalization as well as the difference between the expert and the lay perspective on the criminal process prove determining factors here: in the case of unproblematic culturalizations, cultural otherness is emphasized by the defense attorney as part of an extenuation strategy, while in the problematic cases, it is the defendants themselves who stress the relevance of their being a cultural other. The analysis argues that the judiciary's symbolic self-representation as empty, i.e., as not co-substantial with any social body in particular, lies at the heart of this differential treatment.
Language
English
Source (journal)
Journal of pragmatics: an interdisciplinary quarterly of language studies. - Amsterdam
Publication
Amsterdam : 2009
ISSN
0378-2166
Volume/pages
41:4(2009), p. 806-828
ISI
000264360300010
Full text (Publisher's DOI)
UAntwerpen
Faculty/Department
Research group
Publication type
Subject
Affiliation
Publications with a UAntwerp address
External links
Web of Science
Record
Identification
Creation 20.05.2009
Last edited 16.09.2017
To cite this reference